The fix for In-to-out swing path

Fixing an in-to-out swing path

What is actually happening

The club is travelling right of the target line through impact. With the face closed to that path the ball hooks; with the face square to it the ball is pushed straight right and never comes back. It is frequently the residue of an over-applied slice fix, which is why the miss often changes sides rather than disappearing.

Club path in-to-out, face square to itThe club's path through impact seen from above, drawn for a right-handed golfer, with the feet at the left and the target at the top of the page. A dashed line runs up the page through the ball: the target line. The club's arc crosses the target line at the ball, arriving from inside the line and leaving outside it, so the direction it is travelling at the ball points right of the target. A short solid line at the ball is the clubface. It points along that path, so there is no gap between them and nothing to bend the ball. The figure moves. The clubhead travels the arc at an even speed and draws the path in behind it, carrying the face with it, and the face holds the same aim the whole way rather than turning with the arc. The two readings meet at the ball, which is the only moment either of them decides anything. A ghosted arc shows a path running square to the target line.
  • Target line
  • Club path
  • Clubface
  • Square path
Path right of the line, face square to it

The fix

The club is travelling right of the target line when it meets the ball. It approaches from inside the line, on your side of it, and is still heading outward at impact instead of moving along the line. This page is written for a right-handed golfer, so left-handers should mirror every direction in it.

What the ball does next depends on the face. Where the face points decides, for the most part, where the ball starts, and the gap between face and path decides how much it curves. With the face closed to the path the ball curves left: a small gap gives a draw that starts right and comes back, a large gap gives a hook, and a face that is also left of the target gives a ball that starts left and keeps going. With the face square to the path there is no gap at all, and the ball flies straight right of where you aimed. That is the push, and it never comes back.

Those misses are what separate this fault from two it is often mistaken for. A weak grip leaves the face open, so the ball tends to start right and curve further right. A face aimed off at address can send the ball right with no curve at all, which looks exactly like a push in the air. The difference in both cases is on the ground. With those faults the path can be running down the target line, so the divot points at the target while the ball does not. With an in-to-out path the divot itself points right.

To confirm it, stand behind a few divots taken with a mid-iron and compare them with your target line. Divots pointing right are direct evidence of the path, not an inference from the flight. Then film from behind your hands, with the camera pointing down the target line. The clubhead comes into the ball from well inside the line and carries on out to the right after impact, instead of swinging back to the left of the line as it passes the ball. With a driver, check the strike before blaming the path: a strike toward the toe adds right-to-left curve through gear effect, so a hook with a toe mark on the face is a strike question first.

The path is set before impact, mostly by the setup and by what the body does coming down. The club swings on an arc around you. Aim your feet and shoulders right and the arc tends to tilt right with them. Play the ball too far back and it meets the club early on that arc, while the head is still travelling outward. Let the hips slide toward the target without turning and the path stays right of the target. So check the setup first: body lines parallel to the target line, and the ball no further back than the middle of your stance with a mid-iron. Then, coming down, keep the chest turning toward the target through the ball so the club can swing back left of the line after impact.

The instinctive fix for a hook is to aim further right to leave room for it. That tilts the arc further right, widens the gap between path and face, and bends the ball harder left. The other instinct is to hold the face open through impact. That closes the gap and stops the hook, but the face now matches a path that still points right, so the ball is pushed straight right instead. The miss has changed sides without anything being fixed. It is the same pattern that often creates this path in the first place: a slice cured by swinging further and further out to the right until the curve reverses.

Expect the shape of the shot to change before it settles. As the path moves back toward the target line, whatever the face was doing behind it becomes visible: some shots will start right and drift right, others will start left. That is information about the face rather than a new fault. Fix the path first, then deal with the face.

Drills

Work through them in order. Each one says what it needs before you start.

  1. The exit gate

    Put a headcover on the ground about a foot in front of the ball and a few inches beyond the target line, on the far side from your feet. A path working out to the right carries the club straight into it after impact. Make half-speed swings with a mid-iron, without a ball at first, letting the club swing back left of the line as it passes where the ball would be. Once you miss the headcover ten times in a row, add a ball. Add speed only after five solid strikes in a row that also miss it, and move to full swings when that holds.

    Needs A headcover or a spare glove

  2. Parallel lines at address

    Lay one alignment stick on the ground just beyond the ball, parallel to the target line, and a second parallel to it along your toes. Take your stance, hold a club across the front of your shoulders, and check it on a phone clip taken from behind: it should run parallel to the sticks, not point right of the target. Check the ball against the toe stick as well, no further back than the middle of your stance with a mid-iron. Set up ten times, stepping away between each. Start hitting shots once your shoulders match the sticks on every setup without adjustment.

    Needs Two alignment sticks, or two spare clubs and a phone

  3. Chest-high, left finish

    With a mid-iron, hit three-quarter shots and hold a finish with your chest facing the target and your hands around to the left of your body at about chest height, rather than high and out toward the target. Hold each finish for a count of three. Hit ten, then stand behind the divots. Success is divots pointing at the target and shots that start nearer the target with less curve to the left. When eight of ten divots point at the target, move to full swings with the same finish, and only then take it to the driver.

    Needs nothing but a club

Browse every drill on the site

Practice plan and log

Practise this fix, day by day

Keep a dated log of every session against this fix, so in a few weeks you can read back whether the change has taken instead of trying to remember.

Checkpoints

What to look for to know whether the change has taken.

  • Divots taken with a mid-iron point at the target rather than right of it.
  • On a phone clip from behind, a club held across your shoulders at address runs parallel to the target line rather than aiming right of it.
  • The ball sits no further back than the middle of your stance with a mid-iron.
  • Filmed from behind, the clubhead swings back to the left of the target line after impact instead of carrying on out to the right.
  • Shots start nearer the target and curve left less, or not at all.

Feels

A feel is not a description of what the club does. It is whatever gets your body to do it, and a correct change usually feels exaggerated long before it looks correct.

  • After the ball, the club swings out toward left field.
  • The chest keeps turning until it faces the target and drags the arms around with it.
  • The hands finish low and around you rather than high and out toward the target.

Symptoms that lead here

Each of these can resolve to this cause. If the page above does not match what you are seeing, start from the symptom instead and let the questions narrow it.

If this is not it: causes that produce the same shots

What this rests on

Did this help?

One answer, and nothing is published from it. A fix that keeps getting a no is a fix that is wrong, and this is the only way that shows up.

If something here is wrong, or contradicts what a launch monitor tells you, say so. Corrections change the page.

The weekly fix

One fault a week, written the same way this page is.

One email a week: a fault, its cause, and a drill. Nothing else, and one click to leave. What arrives.

Discussion

Golfers who have worked on this fault, on what helped and what did not. Read it as experience rather than evidence.

Loading the discussion