The fix for Club never enters the sand

Fixing a club that never enters the sand

What is actually happening

The low point arrives at or above the centre of the ball, so the club strikes the ball directly instead of the sand beneath it. The result is the low screamer that clears the green or buries itself in the face, and it comes from the same fear that produces the fat one.

Club enters the sand a long way behind the ballA swing arc seen from in front of a right-handed golfer, so the club travels from left to right and the target is to the right. The ball sits on a band of sand, drawn as a filled surface with grains through it. The arc sweeps down, reaches its lowest point just behind the ball, on the golfer's side of it and under the surface, so the club runs on through the sand, then climbs away again. The club enters the sand a long way behind the ball, and a measured line along the surface shows that gap. The sand between the entry point and the ball is the sand the club throws out, and the ball rides out on it. That is too far behind the ball. The club has to move all the sand in between, so it slows and the ball comes up short. By the time the arc passes the ball it is already climbing, shown by a short straight line drawn at the ball along the arc's direction there. The figure moves. The clubhead sweeps the arc from left to right at an even speed, drawing it in as it goes, and the mark at the entry point comes up to full weight at the moment the head reaches it, so where the club goes into the sand is seen rather than measured.
  • Swing arc
  • Where the club enters the sand
Under the ball, through sand

The fix

The club hits the ball instead of the sand underneath it. On a greenside splash shot the bottom of the swing belongs in the sand: the club goes in an inch or two behind the ball, passes beneath it without touching it, and the sand carries the ball out. With this fault the bottom of the swing arrives level with the middle of the ball or higher, so the leading edge meets the ball and the sand behind it stays smooth. The sand is the cushion between face and ball, and here there is none.

A splash swing is sized to move sand and ball together, and the sand takes much of its speed. With no sand in the way, far more of that speed goes into the ball, struck by the leading edge near its equator, so it leaves low and fast with little of the height the shot needed. That is the screamer that clears the green, or the ball that buries itself in the face of the bunker.

Check the sand before you rake. Smooth sand behind the hollow where the ball sat, or a mark that only begins where the ball was, means the club met the ball first. Little or no sand leaves the bunker, and the strike clicks off the leading edge instead of making the soft thump of a splash. Firm, wet or thin sand makes it more likely, because the club can bounce off a hard surface into the ball instead of sliding in. If your chips from grass are clean, the problem is how you approach the sand, not your swing.

This is the mirror image of entering the sand too far behind the ball, which takes too much sand and leaves the ball in the bunker. Both are one question, where the bottom of the swing goes, answered wrongly in opposite directions, and they grow from the same fear. Leave two in the bunker and the next swing stays shallow to nip the ball off the top, which is this shot. Blade one over the green and the next swing aims a hand's width behind the ball and eases off, which is the heavy one. Neighbouring faults leave different clues. If your weight finishes on your back foot and chips from grass come out thin too, start with the page on hanging back. If the club slows after a long backswing, so that heavy and thin alternate, the fault is deceleration.

The change is aiming the swing at the sand instead of the ball. Work your feet in, which lowers you a little and takes the bottom of the swing down with you. Play the ball a little forward of the middle of your stance with your hands about level with it, not pressed toward the target, and keep a little more weight on your lead foot throughout (the left foot for a right-handed golfer; left-handers mirror this page). Open the face a little in soft sand, and keep it nearer square in firm or wet sand, where a wide-open face lets the club skip off the surface. Look at a spot an inch or two behind the ball, send the club in there and under the ball, and swing through to a full finish. The sand and the loft lift the ball, so your hands do not have to.

The instinctive fixes feed the fault. After a blade, the usual reaction is a gentler swing, and a club that slows down moves the bottom of the swing around, catching the ball's middle one time and too much sand the next. Trying to lift the ball over the lip moves your weight back and brings the club up into the ball. Pressing the hands forward to hit down harder presents the leading edge, which either digs in or catches the ball on its equator. Aiming well behind the ball to be safe only swaps this miss for the heavy one. The answer to both is one spot, an inch or two behind the ball, and a swing that finishes.

Drills

Work through them in order. Each one says what it needs before you start.

  1. Tee under the ball

    In a practice bunker, push a tee straight down into the sand until its head is level with the surface, and sit a ball on it. Your job is to send the tee flying out with the ball, which the club can only do by passing under the ball through the sand. Look at a spot an inch or two behind the ball and hit ten. Success is the tee coming out on eight of them with the ball landing on the green. Then push the tee in until its head is just covered and hit ten more. When those pass, take the tee away and look for the same shallow cut under every ball.

    Needs Tees

  2. Two splashes, then the ball

    In a practice bunker, draw a line in the sand at right angles to the target line, long enough for three swings side by side. Make two swings without a ball, each entering on the line and throwing a shallow slice of sand forward. Then set a ball an inch or two in front of the line and make the third swing exactly like the first two, looking at the line rather than the ball. That is one set. Do ten sets. Success is eight sets in which the cut under the ball starts at the line and matches the two beside it. Then drop to one practice splash before each ball, and finally to none.

    Needs nothing but a club

  3. Firm sand, face check

    Find firm or damp sand, such as a practice bunker after rain. Draw a line, set a ball an inch or two in front of it, and hit five with the face opened wide, then five with it only slightly open, making the same swing each time. Before raking, compare the marks. A skid that skips over the line, or a mark that only starts at the ball, means the club did not get in. A shallow cut starting on the line means it went in. Success is finding the setting that gives four of five cuts starting on the line. Repeat in soft, dry sand, note which setting works there, and on the course use the one that matches the sand you feel underfoot.

    Needs nothing but a club

  4. Rehearse beside the bunker

    On the course a practice swing may not touch the sand, so the routine has to work without one. Build it in the practice bunker: stand just outside, make one rehearsal swing that brushes the grass at the length the shot needs, then step in, work your feet into the sand, pick a spot an inch or two behind the ball and hit the shot looking at that spot. Hit ten, walking out of the bunker between each. Success is eight balls on the green with cuts that start behind the ball. Then use exactly this routine for every greenside bunker shot on the course, high lips and tight flags included.

    Needs nothing but a club

Browse every drill on the site

Practice plan and log

Practise this fix, day by day

Keep a dated log of every session against this fix, so in a few weeks you can read back whether the change has taken instead of trying to remember.

Checkpoints

What to look for to know whether the change has taken.

  • Before raking, a cut in the sand starts an inch or two behind the hollow where the ball sat.
  • A spray of sand leaves the bunker with the ball, and the strike sounds like a soft thump rather than a click.
  • The ball climbs clear of the lip and lands on the green instead of shooting low across it or into the face of the bunker.
  • At address your feet are worked into the sand and your hands are about level with the ball, not pressed toward the target.
  • In firm or wet sand the face sits nearer square than it does in soft, dry sand.

Feels

A feel is not a description of what the club does. It is whatever gets your body to do it, and a correct change usually feels exaggerated long before it looks correct.

  • You are swinging at the sand, and the ball happens to be sitting on it.
  • The club pulls a rug of sand out from under the ball, and the ball leaves with the rug.
  • Your chest is still turning toward the target while the sand is in the air.

Symptoms that lead here

Each of these can resolve to this cause. If the page above does not match what you are seeing, start from the symptom instead and let the questions narrow it.

If this is not it: causes that produce the same shots

What this rests on

Did this help?

One answer, and nothing is published from it. A fix that keeps getting a no is a fix that is wrong, and this is the only way that shows up.

If something here is wrong, or contradicts what a launch monitor tells you, say so. Corrections change the page.

The weekly fix

One fault a week, written the same way this page is.

One email a week: a fault, its cause, and a drill. Nothing else, and one click to leave. What arrives.

Discussion

Golfers who have worked on this fault, on what helped and what did not. Read it as experience rather than evidence.

Loading the discussion